Update: The Sunday Life post was taken down today (16th April) at the request of Eden. You can read Eden’s amazing response here: My Life. On The Line and the beautiful and thoughtful comments from Baby Mac: Ghost Town and Naomi: Owning The Words.
—–
Today four wonderful bloggers and their blogs (Edenland, BabyMac, Kerry Sacville, Under The Yardarm) are featured in a Sunday Life article on “Mummy Blogging”. How fantastic! For those involved in the world of blogging – either as bloggers or readers – it’s no secret that blogging is really taking off in Australia. It’s an exciting time! To see bloggers being talked about in traditional media is always fun.
Then I saw the tweet.
Yikes! That’s a really big mistake about someone’s very real life. This was followed by a tweet from Naomi to say that her dad is very much alive. Another big mistake.
I’ve talked before about how I feel about Sunday Life reporting, so I will openly say here that I headed over to read this post with feelings of trepidation.
Upon reading the introductory remark, my heart sank “readers adore their brutal honesty, their families not so much.”
I absolutely cannot speak for any of the bloggers featured in this story and will be interested to read any of the responses to the article that they may choose to share. I can only tell you the way the article made me feel, both as a blogger and as a regular reader of several of these blogs.
I felt that the author of the piece had selectively chosen comments to create a sensational article. Leaving aside the fact that bloggers don’t need journalists to sensaltionlise their lives (we can do that quite well ourselves, thankyouverymuch) the depth and power that each of those blogs contains was, it felt to me, glossed over in favor of generalizations and sensational ‘tidbits’.
The point of blogging, that in sharing our honest stories bloggers are able to connect with, encourage, motivate and inspire other people who can relate to their experience, was lost. To me, anyway. The question “When these women put their whole lives online for the edification of others, what is left for them – and their families? betrays that the author of this article failed to do her research and to understand what blogging is actually about, and what it means both for the blogger and their readers.
For those who are scratching their heads wondering what this blogging caper is all about, these are some real comments made by blog readers about blogs, in the survey Mum PR and I did into the online habits of Australia women last year.
It’s made me think about what I want in life.
It’s given me hope in life…it’s good to know I’m not alone.
Parenting blogs have changed the way I parent.
Blog posts inspired me to be better every. single. day.
That’s what blogging does.
Once again I feel that the Sunday Life is aiming for provocative instead of positive in this article and that makes me sad, because this article is about real people. Blogging is about the everyday life, of everyday people – making connections about the things we all share in common: our hopes, fears, joys and the crazy, silly things in life. That’s what makes it powerful and what connects us. This article could have been one that showed how beautiful the Mummy blogging phenomena is and why it’s so powerful – and the bloggers featured have so much to offer on that front – instead it focused on an idea that Mummy bloggers just write to get a response and to hell with the consequences. Do any of you know any blogger who writes like that? Are any of you not deeply offended by that assumption?
Keep trying Sunday Life, maybe one day you’ll figure it out.
What did you think about the article? What would you say to a reporter about blogging if you had the chance?
p.s. If by chance, any of the bloggers featured in the article happen to read this post – please know I think you are all wonderful and your stories incredibly powerful. Keep writing, keep being awesome. xx
Incoming search terms:
- sunday life mummy bloggers
- life on the line baby mac
- life on the line mummy bloggers
- mummy bloggers sunday life article
- mummy bloggers sunday life